Return to Today's Full Edition
|
2014 TURF AWARDS
JANUARY 5, 2015
by Kellie Reilly
The Reilly Turf Awards are now in their eighth annual edition. To avoid any
possible reader backlash toward the release of Turf Awards 8, we'll just jump
straight ahead and call my idiosyncratic year-in-review "Turf Awards 8.1 (plus
Updates)."
While this edition features a couple of tweaks, there will be no massive
overhaul to cause disorientation to the unsuspecting. The first installment will
honor the North American performers, in the Turf (T) and Filly & Mare Turf (F&M)
divisions, with a separate volume to follow on the internationals.
And as ever, I hold firm to my decree as the Empress/Kaiserin/Tsarina of
these awards: a horse may be honored in only one category.
Let's go to the start button!
 |
Wise Dan was all heart to prevail in his comeback from colic surgery
(NYRA/Adam Coglianese Photography) |
Bravest Performance in VictoryT: WISE DAN had a real gut problem that forced him to undergo
emergency colic surgery in May. But there's never been anything wrong with
his metaphorical guts, as he proved once again in his victorious comeback in the
August 30
Bernard Baruch Handicap at Saratoga. Under the top weight of 127 pounds, the
sure-fire Hall of Famer fought to keep his nose in front in near course-record
time. That aptly sums up his perfect four-for-four season, which didn't showcase
his old brilliance as much as his implacable will to
triumph over adversity.
F&M: CHARLIE EM was apparently no match for the 3-5 Customer Base turning
for home in the June 26 Possibly Perfect at Santa Anita. Soldiering on in
pursuit, however, Charlie Em was the soul of never-say-die pluck. Customer Base
got an overconfident ride, and Charlie Em had a six-pound pull at the weights,
but her almost-palpable determination made an otherwise forgettable race
memorable.
|
Most Rousing Performance in Defeat
T: SEEK AGAIN made an audacious reappearance in the May 3
Woodford Reserve Turf Classic and nearly stole the show from Wise Dan.
Quickening on the inside, the Juddmonte homebred forced Wise Dan to respond. The
two-time Horse of the Year sought again, and found, that little bit extra to
thwart his rival, who gained stature in defeat. Seek Again could have forced me
to resurrect a couple of other categories for his subsequent outings --
best escape from traffic or
most frustrating trip -- but this one stands out.
F&M: STEPHANIE'S KITTEN came within a neck of overcoming a wide trip,
early trouble, and a pedestrian pace in the July 19
Diana. That kind of tough beat was characteristic of her 2014 campaign, and
the one time she had a reasonable set-up in the September 27
Flower Bowl, the Ken and Sarah Ramsey homebred won. STRATHNAVER merits an
honorable mention for her rattling late run in the June 7
Just a Game, where she missed by a whisker on the head-bob.
 |
Main Sequence was unstoppable in his tail-swishing glory
(Breeders' Cup Ltd. Photo) |
Most Lethal Closing KickT: MAIN SEQUENCE deserves this four times over. His tail-flashing,
last-to-first move in the July 6
United Nations in his U.S. debut was the harbinger of things to come.
Looking up against it in the stretch of the August 17
Sword Dancer, the Graham Motion charge suddenly lurched into gear and got up
in time. Main Sequence cut it fine again in the September 27
Joe Hirsch Turf Classic, prompting me to underestimate him foolishly going
into the November 1
Breeders' Cup Turf. But the Niarchos Family homebred was only saving his
best for last. Readily outkicking the high-class Flintshire, Main
Sequence continued his perfect sequence stateside and enjoyed his most
"comfortable" margin so far -- a half-length.
F&M: LADY ELI was dazzling in the October 31
Breeders' Cup Juvenile Fillies Turf, thereby compelling me to bestow a rare
honor upon a two-year-old. While the Chad Brown pupil had been similarly
emphatic in the Miss Grillo, her performance at Santa Anita made me a believer.
SPARKLING REVIEW gets an honorable mention for inhaling her opponents in both
the October 17
Valley View and the November 15
Mrs. Revere, and remaining unbeaten on turf.
|
Best Front-Running Tour de Force
T: OBVIOUSLY is an obvious choice in this category for the third consecutive
year. A change of venue from old Hollywood to Santa Anita made no difference to
the defending champion in the May 17
American or the June 14
Shoemaker Mile, and he ran his rivals ragged to repeat in both. Honorable mention
goes to BIG KICK for his daring gambit in the June 29
San Juan Capistrano, where he opened up by as many as 10 lengths and held
sway over the whole 1 3/4 miles.
F&M: DAYATTHESPA had a distance question to answer in the November 1
Breeders' Cup Filly & Mare Turf, but the daughter of City Zip exploited her
position of controlling speed. In a textbook case of rating on the front end,
the Chad Brown mare was as relaxed as her name early and had plenty up her
sleeve late. ISTANFORD warrants an honorable mention for defeating males in the
May 24
Arlington Classic, etching her name alongside the likes of Twilight Tear
(1944), But Why Not (1947) and Tosmah (1964). Those champion fillies won in the
race's heyday on dirt, but it's still an accomplishment.
 |
Karakontie and Anodin ran up to their BC Mile bloodlines
(Breeders' Cup Ltd. Photo) |
Most Compelling Pedigree AngleT: KARAKONTIE and ANODIN both had direct pedigree connections to two of the
most illustrious
Breeders' Cup Mile heroines, and the French colts did them proud by running
one-two at Santa Anita. Two-time Mile star Miesque is the great-granddam of
Karakontie, while Anodin is a full brother to three-time Mile legend Goldikova.
Normally Karakontie's 30-1 surprise would have been honored in the "biggest
upset" category. Anytime I get an excuse to mention Miesque and Goldikova,
though, I'll take it -- voila, a new category.
F&M: CROWN QUEEN, a half-sister to three-time Eclipse Award winner Royal
Delta, is living up to her exquisite pedigree for the same connections. The $1.6
million purchase was a rapid improver in 2014, crowning her perfect season in
the October 11
Queen Elizabeth II Challenge Cup. Crown Queen has raced exclusively on turf
so far. Royal Delta, of course, never raced on turf. The tantalizing question
is: will Crown Queen have an opportunity to try dirt for Hall of Fame trainer
Bill Mott in 2015?
|
Most Tantalizing What-Might-Have-Been
T: BAL A BALI, a sensational Triple Crown winner in his native Brazil, was
expected to aim for the Breeders' Cup with new trainer Richard Mandella.
Unfortunately, Fox Hill Farm and Siena Farm's new recruit never made it to the
Hall of Famer's barn.
Bal a Bali came down with laminitis during his interim stop in Miami. The
once-beaten colt has since made a good recovery, and according to the December
19 update on the Fox Hill Farm Facebook page, he was due to ship to Mandella.
Judging by his blistering performances at home, Bal a Bali would have made quite
an impact here. Hopefully we'll get to see the real Bal a Bali this year. On a
much less serious, and downright farcical, note, BROWN PANTHER had a logical
chance of a North American Grade 1 coup in the
Canadian International, if he hadn't run off riderless and gotten himself
scratched at the last minute.
F&M: EURO CHARLINE disposed of an exceptionally deep field of turf
distaffers in the August 16
Beverly D., becoming the first sophomore filly ever to win the Arlington
Million's sister race. The Beverly D. form was advertised again and again for
the rest of the season, culminating in the respective second and third,
Stephanie's Kitten and Just the Judge, filling those same spots in the Breeders'
Cup Filly & Mare Turf. But we never saw Euro Charline again, after the Team
Valor International filly underwent surgery for an ankle chip. Her presence was
sorely missed. The division was also weakened by the absence of RIPOSTE, who
looked bound for big things following fluent victories in the May 24
Sheepshead Bay and June 28
New York, and COFFEE CLIQUE, who made it a perfect three-for-three on the
year in the
Just a Game.
 |
Mr Speaker (right) silenced the eventual Secretariat and Cox Plate winner
(NYRA/Adam Coglianese Photography/Chelsea Durand) |
Biggest UpsetT: MR SPEAKER rallied from last at odds of 23-1 in the July 5
Belmont Derby Invitational, turning in a career-best performance to overrule
Aidan O'Brien's 2-1 hotshot Adelaide (who's on my International honors list). To
be fair, Mr Speaker was eligible to rebound off a subpar effort in the May 26
Pennine Ridge, and a return to his prior turf/synthetic form would give him a
chance. But the Shug McGaughey trainee wielded real authority to bring the gavel
down on Adelaide after the Irish colt appeared to have made the winning move.
More inscrutable was the romp by 39-1 longshot LOCHTE in the February 9
Gulfstream Park Turf, where he upstaged a solid cast in his stakes debut.
F&M: HARD NOT TO LIKE was a bit hard to like in a contentious
Jenny Wiley on April 12, but the 13-1 chance maneuvered through the field
for a last-gasp surprise. It was very much a case of the last shall be first,
for she had been last across the wire in the 2013 edition of the Keeneland
feature.
|
Best Turf Debut
T: CALIFORNIA CHROME looked like a natural on turf in the November 29
Hollywood Derby, to the unmitigated glee of Chromies everywhere. As a
contrarian curmudgeon, I'm duty-bound to note that it wasn't exactly bristling
with stiff competition. Nonetheless, the Kentucky Derby and Preakness star
flashed his considerable talent, making me want to see him back on turf in the
future.
F&M: LEXIE LOU, who was runner-up to Chrome in the Hollywood Derby, is a
fitting honoree in her own division. The Queen's Plate/Woodbine Oaks winner
landed another Canadian major in the August 10 Wonder Where, her first turf
attempt.
 |
Hardest Core was the storyline of Arlington Million week
(Four Footed Fotos) |
Most Heartwarming StoryT: HARDEST CORE's
tale could be a movie script. A useful type when trained by Kiaran
McLaughlin, he was bought as a steeplechase prospect by Greg Bentley for his son
Andrew, who has Down Syndrome. Things went horribly wrong when Hardest Core was
gelded, and he nearly died. After more plot twists regarding his trainers, he
wound up with Eddie Graham, suddenly blossomed on the flat, and upset 2013
Breeders' Cup Turf hero Magician in the August 16
Arlington Million. Andrew's joy made it that much better; he has a gift for
helping us to keep everything in proper perspective. Although not as dramatic a
story, TOM'S TRIBUTE has been a worthy tribute to the late Tom Braly. Racing for
Braly's widow, Marilyn, Tom's Tribute hit the heights at Del Mar last summer
when landing both the July 20
Eddie Read and August 24
Del Mar Mile.
F&M: MOULIN DE MOUGIN and ALEXIS TANGIER, half-sisters out of downhill
machine Cambiocorsa, sent us on a roller-coaster of emotions within the span of
an hour on September 27 at Santa Anita -- but with a happy ending for their
connections, owner/breeder Ran Jan Racing and Hall of Famer Richard Mandella.
Moulin de Mougin, among the top contenders in the
Rodeo Drive, was uncorking a bold circling move on the far turn when she
fell and crashed into the turf. It was heart-in-the-mouth, punch-in-the-gut time
for a few seconds, until she bounced up and galloped off. Moulin de Mougin was
later diagnosed with bone bruising and sent on vacation, but she escaped what
could have been a catastrophe. Jockey Mike Smith was also all right as he came
back to ride Shared Belief to an overland score in the next race, the Awesome
Again. Then came the Unzip Me Stakes, on the downhill turf, and Alexis Tangier
restored her connections' fortune with a winning stakes debut. She proved to be
her mother's daughter, and won one for her half-sister.
|
Most Disappointing Fizzle to a Promising Campaign
T: UP WITH THE BIRDS, who won Canadian Horse of the Year honors along with my
Good Citizenship Award for 2013, has now garnered this dubious distinction.
When he stormed four lengths clear in the July 19 Nijinsky in his third start of
the season, I fully believed that he was back in business. But the Sam-Son Farm
homebred failed to take flight in his ensuing outings. WINNING PRIZE started the
year with a double in the February 1
Arcadia and March 8
Frank E. Kilroe Mile, only to run well below form in two appearances over
the summer and headed to the sidelines. And as a booster of GLOBAL VIEW, it
pains me to note that the Galileo colt didn't build upon his smart score in the
May 3
American Turf.
F&M: MINORETTE accomplished a major career objective by taking the July 5
Belmont Oaks Invitational, becoming the third Grade/Group 1 winner produced
by her dam and enhancing her already lofty value as a broodmare prospect. Judged
in that light, she didn't need to do anything else. But from a fan's viewpoint,
one would have expected her to show more than she subsequently did. As it turned
out, the Belmont Oaks was her high watermark.
 |
Perennial Grade 1 bridesmaid Twilight Eclipse (right) lived in the shadow of Main Sequence
(Bill Denver/Equi-Photo) |
Good Citizenship AwardT: TWILIGHT ECLIPSE showed up in all six U.S. starts, most notably suffering
heartbreakers at the hands of Main Sequence in the United Nations and the Joe
Hirsch Turf Classic. The West Point standard-bearer was also third to his
nemesis in the Sword Dancer and Breeders' Cup Turf (his sixth career Grade 1
placing). Before Main Sequence became the bane of his existence, Twilight
Eclipse justified favoritism in the February 15
Mac Diarmida, threw in his lone clunker abroad in the March 29 Dubai Sheema
Classic, and ran a gallant -- if non-staying -- fourth next time in the two-mile
Belmont Gold Cup on June 6. Although KAIGUN had a few more blemishes, the
Play the King and
Seabiscuit winner should be mentioned for his trio of fine seconds in the
Maker's 46 Mile (to Wise Dan), the June 7 Manhattan and September 14 Woodbine
Mile.
F&M: LA TIA compiled a terrific 8-4-1-2 mark while racing on both turf
and Polytrack in 2014. The only time she didn't crack the top three was in the
loaded Beverly D., but the confirmed front runner still held on tough for
fourth. The Illinois-bred capped her productive campaign with consecutive wins
in the October 12
Athenia and November 30
Matriarch, earning a Grade 1 laurel in the latter. PARRANDA was a warrior
all year, as her 10-4-2-2 record attests. Moreover, she mixed it up in good
company on both coasts for two different sets of connections -- for
Lone Stable and trainer Rodolfo Garcia at Gulfstream and for a partnership
including
Hall of Famer Jerry Hollendorfer in California.
|
Most Captivating Race Name that Proved Prophetic
The inaugural
Dueling Grounds Derby
witnessed a protracted duel between pacesetter MY AFLEET and Medal Count, and
neither gave any quarter in their skirmish. As I wrote in the recap: "Refusing
to flinch after Medal Count fired his best shot, My Afleet responded with a
last-gasp volley of his own to prevail by a pixel."
Special Award for Most Astute Plundering
Newmarket-based trainer David Simcock masterminded a Grade 1 double in his
September 14 raid on Woodbine. SHEIKHZAYEDROAD was the first to oblige in the
Northern Dancer Turf, and TRADE STORM followed up in the
Woodbine Mile. One month later, Simcock pulled off another heist courtesy of
CASPAR NETSCHER -- whom he's nurtured back to top form after a failed stint at
stud -- in the October 19
Nearctic. And if MOMENT IN TIME hadn't endured a world of trouble in the
August 16
American St Leger, Simcock would probably have had four big North American
wins in 2014.
 |
Dance with Fate had untapped potential
(Keeneland/Coady Photography) |
In MemoriamTragically, we lost LAUGHING to colic at this time last year, just a few days
after honoring her with our
Comeback Player of the Year Award. The well-traveled VAGABOND SHOES had been
happy to call Southern California home, for the seven-year-old gelding was in a
purple patch of form, before
breaking down fatally in the March 22 San Luis Rey. Blue Grass hero DANCE WITH FATE
died after suffering irreparable injuries in a
freak training accident on July 24 at Del Mar. The Peter Eurton trainee had
raced on turf only once, but his convincing win in a Santa Anita allowance last
January stamped him as one to follow on the surface. Fate never gave him another
dance on the turf.
|
 Send this article to a friend
|
|