While much of the attention ahead of Friday’s Grade 1, $250,000
Matriarch Stakes focused on the older turf mares, led by 4-5 favorite Never
Retreat, a pair of three-year-old fillies ended up stealing the show from their
elders. George Krikorian’s homebred Star Billing couldn’t quite run down Summer
Soiree when they met in the Grade 1 Del Mar Oaks two starts back, or when both
faltered in the Grade 1 Queen Elizabeth II Challenge Cup at Keeneland last time.
It was a different story back over her home turf at Hollywood Park As
Summer Soiree boldly attempted to wire the field, Star Billing rallied along the
rail in deep stretch and foiled her by a half-length, with Never Retreat a
well-beaten third.
Trained by John Shirreffs and beautifully ridden by Victor Espinoza, Star
Billing dropped back and angled over from post 7, securing a ground-saving trip
off the pace. Up front, Summer Soiree had broken smartly and went straight to
the lead. As the Graham Motion trainee carved out fractions of :24 4/5 and :48
4/5, a rank Quiet Oasis stalked in second. Fellow Motion runner Unbridled Humor
skimmed the rail behind her stablemate, but Never Retreat was parked outside and
didn’t look entirely comfortable. Star Billing drafted in the slipstream of
Unbridled Humor. Defending champion Gypsy’s Warning, another of Motion’s trio,
was followed by Madera Castana and Up in Time.
Summer Soiree kept rolling through six furlongs in 1:12 3/5. Unbridled Humor
peeled off the fence to launch her bid on the outside of the pacesetter, but
Star Billing stuck to the inside path as she crept into contention. At the rear,
Up in Time was in close quarters behind Gypsy’s Warning and Madera Castana, and
she clipped heels rounding the far turn. As she stumbled, dove forward and lost
her balance, Up in Time tossed Martin Garcia onto the turf. She continued to
gallop riderless the rest of the way. Thankfully, both horse and rider were
apparently fine at first report.
Meanwhile, Summer Soiree was still in full flight down the stretch, leaving
her older rivals toiling. Unbridled Humor could make no headway, and Never
Retreat was taking a while to gather momentum after spinning wide and losing
position on the turn. But Star Billing was beginning to gain ground. Finding her
best stride late, she wore down a stubborn Summer Soiree to finish the firm-turf
mile in 1:35 2/5.
“She was really unbelievable today,” Espinoza said. “On the first turn,
everybody started moving out, so I cut the corner without having to jerk her
around or do too much with her. By the three-eighths pole I was following Summer
Soiree. The jockey on Summer Soiree (Gabriel Saez) switched the whip to his left
hand and I thought he might drift out, and that was my chance. When I got
alongside the other horse, my filly got a little intimidated, but I hit her
left-handed one time and she just took off. It worked out perfectly.”
“I got her to settle real well,” Saez said of Summer Soiree. “The last eighth
of a mile (Star Billing) kind of snuck through. I tried to open up a little bit
on the turn, but these are good horses. She was trying to come back on. She
galloped out very strongly.”
Both sophomores went off at attractive prices in their first try against
their elders. Star Billing, a 10-1 chance in the wake of four straight losses,
rewarded her loyalists with $23.40, $9 and $3.80. The 7-1 Summer Soiree ended
the $71.60 exacta ($1).
Never Retreat was along for third, another 2 1/4 lengths adrift, in what was
her career finale. She nabbed Unbridled Humor by a head, relegating her to
fourth.
“She did the same thing (drifted out around the turn) at Churchill Downs when
we ran her there (sixth in the Grade 2 Distaff Turf Mile) on Derby Day,” Team
Block’s Dave Block said. “She backed off on the turn and then made a run. We
didn’t expect her to do it again today. She finished up great and that’s just
how the game is. This was it today. She’s going to the breeding shed and will be
bred to War Front.”
Motion commented on his trio.
“The winner was the same filly who almost got us (Summer Soiree) in the Del
Mar Oaks,” the horseman said. “But she ran a huge race. Actually all three ran
their race. Gypsy’s Warning (fifth) just came a little too late, and Unbridled
Humor was right where (jockey) Ramon (Dominguez) wanted to be.
“I think a mile might be Summer Soiree’s best distance because you don’t have
to finesse her as much. They are all going to leave Sunday with (Grade 1
Hollywood Turf Cup winner) Sanagas. Summer Soiree will get a little break now.
Unbridled Humor could run back in the Florida Millions (in January at Gulfstream
Park) and Gypsy’s Warning more than likely will be bred.”
Gypsy’s Warning was followed by Quiet Oasis and Madera Castana. The stewards
posted the inquiry sign to review the incident involving Up in Time on the far
turn. Deeming the replay inconclusive, they did not assign responsibility to any
party and made no change to the order of finish. All Star Heart was scratched.
The first three-year-old to take the Matriarch since Price Tag in 2006, Star
Billing improved her record to 7-3-2-1, $355,067. She looked like a filly who
was going places this spring, so Friday’s victory is a case of promise
fulfilled. Right off her debut maiden win sprinting down the hill at Santa
Anita, Shirreffs pitched her into the Grade 3 Senorita at a mile here on May 7.
The bay responded to the class hike with a convincing 2 3/4-length decision over
the Matriarch course and distance.
Star Billing followed up with a close second in the Grade 2 Honeymoon
Handicap, but a bobble at the start cost her in the Grade 1 American Oaks. She
found herself farther back than expected, rolled home late, and missed by all of
a head in third. Star Billing again finished fast from off the pace in the Del
Mar Oaks, but came up a half-length short of catching Summer Soiree. The two ran
well below form in the October 15 Queen Elizabeth II, where Summer Soiree
uncharacteristically faded to fifth and Star Billing was a non-threatening
sixth.
“She runs pretty well at any track — except Keeneland,” Espinoza said. “When
I rode her last time there, she didn’t handle the track at all. I knew you could
just forget about that race.”
“She’s run really well on this course,” Shirreffs noted. “The track was a
little soft, a little loose for her at Keeneland. She didn’t handle it very
well. She hasn’t had things go her way a few times, but she’s obviously a really
nice filly. I’ll have to talk to George (Krikorian) about where she’ll go next.”
By Dynaformer, the Kentucky-bred Star Billing is a three-quarter sister to
multiple Grade 1-winning millionaire Starrer, also by Dynaformer. Star Billing
is the first registered foal from the unraced Thunder Gulch mare Topliner, who
is herself a half-sister to Starrer and another multiple Grade 1-winning
millionaire in Stellar Jayne.